Comparing 5 Fireplace Products: A Comprehensive Review

Hey there! If you’re in the market for a new fireplace or fire pit burner, you’ve come to the right place. In this article, we’ll be reviewing and comparing a few different options for you to consider. Whether you’re looking to add some warmth to your home or create a cozy outdoor gathering spot, these products have got you covered.

Fireplaces and fire pits have been a staple in homes for centuries, providing both heat and ambiance. In the past, traditional wood-burning fireplaces and pits were the norm, but with advancements in technology, there are now many types of gas-powered options available. The benefits of these gas-powered products are numerous. They offer convenience, as they can be easily ignited and controlled with the flip of a switch or the turn of a knob. They also produce less smoke and ash, eliminating the need for constant maintenance and cleaning. Plus, they can be used with both natural gas and liquid propane, giving you flexibility in fuel options.

Now let’s take a closer look at the products we’ll be discussing in this article. We have the Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set, which boasts a 30,000 BTU output and can heat up to 1000 square feet. It’s designed to mimic the appearance of stacked red oak logs, creating a realistic and cozy fire experience. Next up is the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring, made from durable 304 stainless steel. With a maximum BTU of 443,000, this burner is perfect for creating a warm and inviting atmosphere in your outdoor space. Moving on, we have the ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove, a freestanding fireplace and indoor space heater. With a 25,000 BTU output, this appliance can heat up to 1,100 square feet, making it a great option for smaller spaces. Lastly, we have the Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 32-Inch Intermediate Gas vent-free stove. This stove offers 30,000 BTUs of heat and features a sleek black design that will complement any home decor.

Stay tuned as we dive deeper into each product’s features, pros, and cons, helping you make the best choice for your needs.

Duluth Forge Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat and Dual Fuel Options, 30,000 BTU, Heats up to 1000 Sq. Ft, Stacked Red Oak, 18 Inches

Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat, Use with Natural Gas or Liquid Propane, 30000 BTU, Heats up to 1000 Sq. Ft, Stacked Red Oak, 18 Inches

This image is property of Amazon.com.

The Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat is designed to provide efficient and convenient heating for up to 1000 sq. ft. Whether you have a natural gas or liquid propane supply, this fireplace logs set offers the flexibility to use either fuel source.

There are several reasons why we highly recommend the Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat. Firstly, its dual fuel technology allows you to choose between natural gas and liquid propane. This versatility ensures that you can use the product regardless of your available fuel supply.

Another standout feature is the high level of efficiency provided by the 30000 BTU vent-free gas burner. This burner is incredibly efficient, with a rating of 99.9%. This means that almost all of the heat generated will be used to warm up your space, reducing energy waste and ultimately saving you money on heating costs.

Furthermore, this fireplace logs set doesn’t require an outside duct or chimney for installation. This eliminates the need for complex and expensive installation processes, making it an ideal option for those who want a hassle-free heating solution.

The Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat is designed to provide effective heating for spaces up to 1000 sq. ft. Its primary purpose is to offer a convenient and efficient alternative to traditional fireplaces.

One of the key features of this product is its dual fuel technology. This allows you to choose between natural gas and liquid propane, giving you the freedom to use the fuel source that best suits your needs. Additionally, the 30000 BTU vent-free gas burner ensures powerful and consistent heat output.

With a stacked red oak design, this fireplace logs set brings a touch of elegance and sophistication to any room. The realistic log appearances combined with the flickering flames create a cozy and inviting atmosphere, enhancing the overall ambiance of your space.

The inclusion of a thermostat adds to the convenience of this product, allowing you to set and maintain your desired temperature effortlessly. This ensures that your space remains comfortable without the need for constant adjustments.

The overall quality of the Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat is exceptional. The craftsmanship and attention to detail are evident, with the stacked red oak logs and realistic flames providing a lifelike fireplace experience.

Additionally, the dual fuel technology and high efficiency of the 30000 BTU vent-free gas burner showcase the product’s superior performance. The ability to heat up to 1000 sq. ft. without the need for external ducts or chimneys further demonstrates its high-quality design.

  • Dual fuel technology offers the flexibility to use natural gas or liquid propane

  • High efficiency with a 99.9% rating for the vent-free gas burner

  • No outside duct or chimney required for installation

  • Realistic design with stacked red oak logs and flickering flames

  • Thermostat included for easy temperature control

  • May require professional installation if you are not familiar with gas appliances

  • The size of the logs set may not be suitable for smaller spaces

The Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat is a top-quality heating option that combines efficiency, convenience, and aesthetics. Its dual fuel technology, high BTU rating, and realistic design make it a standout choice for heating spaces up to 1000 sq. ft.

Duluth Forge Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat and Dual Fuel Options, 30,000 BTU, Heats up to 1000 Sq. Ft, Stacked Red Oak, 18 Inches

Stanbroil 36″ Fire Pit Burner Ring – Natural Gas and Propane Fire Pit – 304 Stainless Steel – Indoor and Outdoor – Max BTU 443,000

Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring for Natural Gas  Propane Fire Pit Fireplace - 304 Stainless Steel Fire Pit Burner for Indoor  Outdoor, BTU 443,000 Max

This image is property of Amazon.com.

The Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring is designed for both indoor and outdoor use in natural gas or propane fire pit fireplaces. Its primary use is to provide a reliable and efficient source of heat and flames for a cozy and inviting atmosphere in any outdoor entertaining space.

There are several reasons why we highly recommend the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring for your fireplace needs. Firstly, its construction with 304 stainless steel ensures durability even under extreme heat and severe weather conditions. This guarantees that you can enjoy the benefits of this fire pit for years to come.

Additionally, this fire pit burner ring is whistle-free, thanks to the fact that all the holes are drilled, not punched. This promotes smoother gas flow and eliminates any annoying whistling sounds that could disrupt your tranquil outdoor experience.

The purpose of the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring is to create a cozy and inviting atmosphere in your outdoor entertaining space. It is specifically designed for use with both natural gas and propane, making it versatile and flexible for different fuel options.

The key features of this fire pit burner ring include its 443,000 BTU Max rating, which ensures a powerful and impressive flame height. The design of the burner ring, with concentric rings that increase in diameter, further enhances the flame height and creates a visually stunning fire display.

When it comes to overall quality, the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring exceeds expectations. Its 304 stainless steel construction guarantees durability and resistance to extreme heat and severe weather conditions. This ensures that your fire pit burner ring will maintain its functionality and aesthetic appeal over time.

The whistle-free design is also a testament to its quality, as it demonstrates attention to detail and customer satisfaction. With a product that burns quietly and smoothly, you can enjoy a peaceful and relaxing ambiance without any annoying distractions.

Pros:

  • Durable 304 stainless steel construction for long-lasting use
  • Whistle-free design for a quiet and relaxing burning experience
  • Versatile for use with both natural gas and propane
  • Impressive 443,000 BTU Max rating for a powerful flame height

Cons:

  • Requires installation of an air mixer with propane gas burning fire features
  • Some users may find the 36-inch diameter size too large for their space

Considering the pros and cons, the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring offers exceptional quality and functionality for creating a cozy and inviting ambiance in your outdoor entertaining space. With its durable construction, whistle-free design, and powerful flame height, this fire pit burner ring is a reliable choice for all your fireplace needs.

Stanbroil 36 Fire Pit Burner Ring - Natural Gas and Propane Fire Pit - 304 Stainless Steel - Indoor and Outdoor - Max BTU 443,000

Refurbished ProCom Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove: Fireplace & Space Heater

ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove, Freestanding Fireplace and Indoor Space Heater, Use with Natural Gas or Liquid Propane, Heats up to 1,100 Square Feet, 25,000 BTU, Refurbished

This image is property of Amazon.com.

The ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove, Freestanding Fireplace, and Indoor Space Heater are designed for use in indoor spaces up to 1,100 square feet. It utilizes either natural gas or liquid propane as fuel to generate up to 25,000 BTUs of heat. This versatile product serves as both a decorative fireplace and a space heater, providing warmth and ambiance to any room in your home.

There are several reasons why we like the ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove. Firstly, its dual fuel technology allows you to choose between natural gas and liquid propane, providing flexibility in fuel options. This feature is especially beneficial for households that have access to both types of fuel or want the option to switch between them.

Secondly, the included thermostat control ensures that the room is heated to your desired temperature. The built-in thermostat automatically cycles the heater on and off to maintain a comfortable warmth, without the need for constant manual adjustments. This not only saves energy but also ensures a consistent level of warmth in the room.

Furthermore, this product is 99.9% efficient with its vent-free gas burner. This means that all the heat produced is directed into the room, without any wastage through outside ducts or chimneys. This makes it an economical choice for heating your home, as there is no heat loss during the ventilation process.

The ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove serves as a decorative fireplace and a space heater. It features a space-saving design, making it suitable for smaller rooms without compromising on performance. The realistic-looking logs provide an aesthetically pleasing visual, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere in your home.

One of the key features of this product is its ability to heat up to 1,100 square feet, making it suitable for a wide range of room sizes. Whether you want to warm up a small bedroom or a spacious living room, this product is designed to meet your heating needs. Its compact dimensions of 25″ H x 33.5″ W x 13″ and lightweight construction of 49.8 lbs make it easy to move and position according to your desired room layout.

The ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove prioritizes safety with its built-in pilot oxygen depletion sensor (ODS). This feature immediately shuts down the gas heater if carbon monoxide or lack of oxygen is detected, ensuring the well-being of you and your loved ones. Additionally, the battery-assisted piezo ignition provides a reliable and convenient way to start the heater, eliminating the need for matches or lighters.

The ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove is a refurbished product that includes all the original accessories, guaranteeing its quality and performance. This heater is built to last and is backed by ProCom’s reputation for producing reliable and durable heating solutions. Its efficient heating capabilities, safety features, and stylish design make it a top choice for homeowners looking for a versatile fireplace and space heater.

  • Dual fuel technology provides flexibility in fuel options

  • Built-in thermostat control ensures desired room temperature

  • 99.9% efficient with vent-free gas burner, saving energy and minimizing heat loss

  • Realistic-looking logs and space-saving design enhance the ambiance of any room

  • Safety features such as oxygen depletion sensor and piezo ignition

  • The refurbished nature of the product may have slight aesthetic imperfections

  • Limited availability compared to brand new models

The ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove, Freestanding Fireplace, and Indoor Space Heater are a reliable and efficient heating solution for your home. With its dual fuel technology, thermostat control, and safety features, this refurbished product provides warmth, style, and peace of mind. Upgrade your home’s heating system with this versatile fireplace and space heater.

Refurbished ProCom Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove: Fireplace  Space Heater

Black Intermediate Gas vent free stove

Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas vent free stove, Black

This image is property of Amazon.com.

The Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas Vent Free Stove is a versatile and efficient heating solution for your home. It is designed to provide ample warmth and create a cozy atmosphere in rooms up to 1,000 square feet. This gas vent-free stove operates on either LP or NG fuel, giving you the flexibility to choose the fuel source that suits your needs.

We are particularly impressed with the built-in thermostat and overheat sensor of the Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT stove. The thermostat allows you to set and maintain your desired room temperature, ensuring optimal comfort. The overheat sensor ensures safety by automatically shutting off the stove if it detects excessive heat, protecting you and your home from potential hazards.

The primary purpose of the Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT gas vent-free stove is to provide efficient and reliable heating for your living space. It is designed with a dual burner system that provides two rows of flames, creating a realistic and beautiful fire effect. This adds to the ambiance of the room and gives the appearance of a full-looking fire.

Key features of this gas vent-free stove include its 30,000 BTU/hr heating capacity, cold rolled steel construction for durability, and its compact dimensions of 14.37” D x 31.93” W x 28.27” H. The firebox dimensions are 12.25” D x 26.07” W x 12.08” H. It also has a clearance space requirement of 5” minimum from the wall and 36” minimum above the stove.

The Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT gas vent-free stove is built with high-quality materials and craftsmanship. Its cold rolled steel construction ensures durability and longevity, allowing you to enjoy the warmth and ambiance it provides for years to come. The stove is also designed to meet the highest safety standards, exemplified by its built-in thermostat and overheat sensor. These features not only enhance convenience but also prioritize your safety and well-being.

Pros:

  • Versatile dual fuel technology (LP or NG)
  • Beautiful and realistic dual burner system
  • Built-in thermostat for precise temperature control
  • Overheat sensor for safety
  • Suitable for rooms up to 1,000 square feet

Cons:

  • Blower not included (sold separately)
  • Potential exposure to chemicals, as indicated by the product description

The Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas Vent Free Stove in Black is a reliable and efficient heating solution for your home. Its dual burner system, built-in thermostat, and overheat sensor make it a standout product. With its versatile fuel options, it can accommodate your specific needs. While the absence of a blower may be a drawback, the overall quality and performance of this gas vent-free stove make it a valuable addition to any living space.

Black Intermediate Gas vent free stove

Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Fireplace Burner Kit

Stanbroil 16.5 Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit

This image is property of Amazon.com.

The Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit is designed for use in natural gas fireplaces. It provides a beautiful and realistic flame display, making it a perfect addition to any indoor or outdoor living space.

There are several reasons why we highly recommend the Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit. Firstly, its triple flame design creates a stunning and captivating flame effect that adds warmth and ambiance to any environment. The triple row burner construction ensures even distribution of flames, resulting in an incredible visual display.

Additionally, this fireplace burner kit is made from high-quality powder-coated steel, which not only enhances its durability but also adds an elegant touch to the overall appearance. The burner is pre-installed at the factory, and all plumbing is hidden below the tray, providing a professional-looking finish.

Furthermore, the Stanbroil Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit includes a 12-inch flex line and connection fittings, making installation quick and easy. It also comes with a damper clamp, ensuring proper ventilation and safety.

The Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit is designed to transform your fireplace into a focal point of beauty and warmth. With its triple flame design and high-quality construction, this burner kit offers a unique and captivating flame display.

Key features of this product include:

  • Triple flame design for a stunning visual effect.
  • Triple row burner construction for even distribution of flames.
  • High-quality powder-coated steel construction for durability and aesthetics.
  • Easy installation with pre-installed burner, hidden plumbing, and included connection fittings.
  • Applicability to natural gas fireplaces, with the option to use propane gas with the addition of an air mixer.
  • BTU rating of 60,000, providing ample heat output for any space.
  • Included flex line, connection fittings, and damper clamp for convenient installation and safety.

The Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit is built with exceptional quality in mind. The use of powder-coated steel ensures its longevity, while the triple row burner construction guarantees an even distribution of flames for an impressive visual effect.

Furthermore, the inclusion of necessary installation components, such as the pre-installed burner, hidden plumbing, and connection fittings, showcases the meticulous attention to detail in this product’s design. The overall build and finish reflect a high level of craftsmanship, making this fireplace burner kit a reliable and long-lasting investment.

Pros of the Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit include:

  • Captivating triple flame design for a stunning flame display.
  • High-quality powder-coated steel construction adds durability and elegance.
  • Easy installation with pre-installed burner and hidden plumbing.
  • Flexibility to use natural gas or propane gas with an air mixer.
  • Included connection fittings ensure a hassle-free installation process.
  • Ample heat output with a BTU rating of 60,000.

Cons of this product include:

  • Limited use for natural gas or propane gas fireplaces only.
  • Air mixer required when using propane gas.
  • May require professional installation for inexperienced individuals.

The Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit offers a visually stunning flame display, high-quality construction, and convenient installation. Whether you’re looking to upgrade your indoor or outdoor fireplace, this burner kit is an excellent choice for adding warmth, beauty, and ambiance to any space.

Stanbroil 16.5 Natural Gas Fireplace Burner Kit

Comparison of Fireplace Products

Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat

  • Ventless dual fuel technology: Can be fueled with either natural gas or liquid propane
  • 30,000 BTU vent-free gas burner: 99.9% efficient
  • Heats up to 1000 sq. ft.
  • No outside duct or chimney required

Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring for Natural Gas & Propane Fire Pit Fireplace

  • Measures 36″ in diameter
  • Made from 304 stainless steel construction
  • Suitable for vented indoor or outdoor natural gas or propane burning fire features (requires installation of an air mixer with propane)
  • Rated BTU max: 443,000
  • Includes burner ring, inlet plug and wrench, and installation manual

ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove

  • 25,000 BTU dual fuel technology: Can be powered by natural gas or liquid propane
  • Heats up to 1,100 sq. ft.
  • Built-in thermostat control
  • 99.9% efficient with vent-free gas burner
  • Safe with battery-assisted Piezo ignition and built-in pilot oxygen depletion sensor

Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas Vent Free Stove

  • Stove dimensions: 14.37” D x 31.93” W x 28.27” H
  • Firebox dimensions: 12.25” D x 26.07” W x 12.08” H
  • Coverage of up to 1,000 sq. ft.
  • Built-in thermostat and overheat sensor
  • Dual fuel technology (LP or NG) with up to 30,000 BTU/hr

Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit

  • Pan dimensions: 16.5″L x 14″W x 1.85″ H
  • Triple row burner construction with 3/4″ L x 1/2″ male connection hubs on both ends
  • Suitable for natural gas; an air mixer is required for propane gas
  • 60,000 BTU
  • Includes triple flame pan burner, 12-inch flex line, connection fittings, and damper clamp
Product Fuel Type BTU Heating Area Dimensions Features
Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat Natural Gas or Liquid Propane 30,000 Up to 1000 sq. ft. 18 Inches Ventless, efficient, no outside duct or chimney required
Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring for Natural Gas & Propane Fire Pit Fireplace Natural Gas or Propane 443,000 Max 36 Inch Made from 304 stainless steel, suitable for indoor or outdoor use, creates cozy feeling
ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove Natural Gas or Liquid Propane 25,000 Up to 1,100 sq. ft. Built-in thermostat control, efficient, safe with oxygen depletion sensor
Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas vent free stove Natural Gas or Liquid Propane 30,000 Up to 1,000 sq. ft. 32-Inch Built-in thermostat, overheat sensor, dual fuel technology
Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit Natural Gas 60,000 16.5″ Triple row burner, suitable for natural gas, professional looking finish

Note: The heating area for the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring and the Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit is not specified in the product details.

Conclusion

Overall, after reviewing all five products, it can be concluded that each has its own unique features and benefits. However, there are some drawbacks to consider for each product.

Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat

This fireplace log set is highly versatile as it can be used with both natural gas and liquid propane. It has a high BTU output of 30000, making it suitable for heating up to 1000 sq. ft. However, one drawback is that it only comes in a stacked red oak design, limiting the customization options for users.

Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring

This fire pit burner ring is made of 304 stainless steel and can be used with both natural gas and propane. It has a high BTU output of 443,000, making it perfect for both indoor and outdoor use. However, the size may not be suitable for smaller fire pits, so it is important to measure your fire pit before purchasing.

ProCom QNSD250T-R Vent Free Dual Fuel Stove

This dual fuel stove is a freestanding fireplace and indoor space heater. It can be used with both natural gas and liquid propane and has a BTU output of 25,000, heating up to 1,100 square feet. However, being a refurbished product, it may not be as reliable as a brand new unit.

Pleasant Hearth VFS2-PH30DT 30,000 BTU 32-Inch Intermediate Gas vent free stove

This gas vent free stove has a high BTU output of 30,000 and can heat up to 32 inches. It is a great option for those looking for an intermediate-sized stove. However, being vent-free, it may not be suitable for those with ventilation concerns or allergies.

Stanbroil 16.5″ Natural Gas Powder Coated Steel Fireplace Triple Flame Pan Burner Kit

This triple flame pan burner kit is made of powder-coated steel and is suitable for natural gas. It has a compact size of 16.5 inches, making it perfect for smaller fireplaces. However, it may not provide enough heat for larger spaces.

Based on these conclusions, it is recommended that the Duluth Forge DLS-18T-2 Dual Fuel Ventless Fireplace Logs Set with Thermostat is the best choice for a fireplace log set, as it is highly versatile and can heat up a large area. However, for those with smaller fire pits, the Stanbroil 36 Inch Round Fire Pit Burner Ring is recommended due to its high BTU output and durable stainless steel construction. Ultimately, the specific audience for these products would be homeowners or individuals looking to enhance their fireplace or fire pit experiences.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.